Firefly Magazines

What an editorial review actually checks

By Barrington Kirkham,

Every submission is read by a person before it publishes. Here is what they are looking for, and the things that most often send a piece back.

Nothing publishes on a Firefly title without a person reading it. That is the whole point of editorial review, and it is worth being open about what happens in it.

Is it true, and can we tell

Names, dates, places and numbers get checked where they can be. Superlatives get questioned. If a claim cannot be supported, it comes out or the piece goes back.

Is it clear

Editors will cut, tighten and rewrite headlines. Length matters less than whether the first paragraph earns the second.

Is it legal and fair

Named individuals, images of people, anything touching a regulated sector, anything involving minors. These get real scrutiny, and they are the most common reason a piece is held rather than rejected.

Is it what it says it is

Promotional content is fine and gets labelled. Promotional content dressed as independent editorial is not, and reclassifying it is one of the least popular things we do.

What happens next

Accepted, edited and accepted, sent back with notes, or declined with a reason. Payment does not shorten review and does not guarantee publication. That is deliberate: the moment it did, review would be theatre.

More from the Firefly Magazines blog